.: Critical Thinking or Mind Control, Homeschooling, martial ar
Critical Thinking or Mind Control
Homeschooling, martial arts, and the nature of education in a post 9/11 world.
The words, “Tai-kwon-do”, then “U-S-A”, then “Ko-re-a” rang out from the lips of a dozen or so children ages six to nine in accompaniment to a right-left-right punching combination. Focus was a bit lacking, there was little hip involvement, and some of the participants looked more than a little awkward; but the enthusiasm was ever so present as they shouted the words at the top of their lungs.
Clearly the meaning of the words was not the point of the exercise. Far more poignant to me than any words they might be shouting was that very fact -- the fact that the meaning of the words was not the point. “Veg-e-mite” or “eggs-and-Spam” would have done just as well. This is frightening. Particularly in the days since 9-11, frustration and fear have inspired many forms of patriotic fervor, one particular flavor of which I was seeing that day in the Tai Kwon Do studio that my eight-year-old daughter and I were visiting in hopes of finding an activity she would like. I felt significant relief in discovering that she was no more inspired by the class than I.
In their gis, the uniform of the martial art, and sporting a variety of coveted stripes on their belts signifying ranking and authority, their response to each directive was a reflexive "Sir!" with all the fealty and implication of absolute reverence for authority that that form of address implies. The scene brought to mind not so much American patriotism as the memorable ancient black and white images of a boy beating a drum and rows upon rows of smartly uniformed youth chanting in unison in Leni Riefenstahl’s "Triumph of the Will", the great Nazi propaganda film for which the Nuremberg rallies were largely staged. About the same age as my daughter, the boys and girls of the “Hitler Jugend” and “Bund Deutscher Mädel” who participated there, beating their drums, singing their songs, chanting their slogans, gave no more thought to the larger picture than did these incipient martial artists before me propelling their tiny fists upon command into imaginary adversaries.
In an effort to transcend mere training and provide an education, our California educational system has, in a move of perhaps uncharacteristic circumspection, attempted to include in every class a substantial “critical thinking” component. Each proposed new course outline must contain such a component consisting, at the very least, of outside readings in primary or secondary sources which can put the dictates of the textbook into perspective by providing alternative points of view.
I rejected as inappropriate and probably very impolite the impulse to ask the presiding Tai kwon do master about the critical thinking component of his class and whether similarly jingoistic chants, altered to fit local allegiances, would be used by Tai kwon do studios in other countries. Such practices certainly fit well into the mind-homogenizing rhetoric of North Korea and the People’s Republic of China where rhythmic chanted government endorsed slogans are compulsory everyday fare. It also occurred to me that if other words were substituted in that three punch combination, such as “Slo-bo-dan,” “Mu-ga-be,” or even “O-sam-a” that these children would comfortably make the transition without a murmur.
In the past year many people have wondered at the mindset that could inspire persons to take their own lives in an act whose purpose is to bring misery, suffering, and death to others. In whose philosophy or creed is it taught that eternal rewards await a person who has performed such an act? The mystery baffles many and engenders much rancorous suspicion and distrust. Whatever the doctrine is that condones and legitimizes such actions, one very clear conclusion is unavoidable: The critical thinking component is lacking!
Clearly a very powerful force is brought to bear when fervor of any sort takes hold or is instilled and when act, reflex, and performance are divorced from perspicacity and conscience. Military training the world over attempts to create a reflexive response through constant repetition against such time that a soldier will be faced with taking lives. This ensures that any impulse to think will be overwhelmed by the intended automatic programmed response. Whether the “divine wind” of the kamikaze or the religious zeal of the Al Queda terrorist, it is the training methodology that is responsible for removing the critical thinking component from the equation and it is the absence of that component that makes possible the acts that we have seen replayed again and again so vividly. The underlying ideology is no longer relevant once the slogan is chanted and the critical mind has been turned off. Ideologues of any stripe who have relinquished the practice of critical thinking, including patriots, make good cannon fodder – and good suicide terrorists.
How then can we miss seeing the fact that our response to terrorism has largely been to assume a stance of patriotism, rallying in unguarded support of our particular nation, creed, or whatever sociological division we identify with and that we are commonly omitting the all-important critical thinking factor? Is this response not supporting exactly that mindset that is responsible for such dastardly acts? Indeed, shouldn’t our response to such acts be quite the opposite, to vilify worldwide the practices of rote indoctrination, state controlled media, and mindless flag waving as being beneath the dignity and responsibility of conscientious sentient beings capable of sagacious, rational thought? And should we not do this by example?
After looking into a number of martial arts schools with very similar procedures with my daughter, we found an Aikido class with a very positive atmosphere and an enlightened and inspiring instructor. Some lengthy discussion in our homeschooling family resulted from the experience, particularly on the question of how best to teach critical thinking. All appreciated with hilarity the incongruity of the militaristic rote approach we’d seen in the Tai kwon do class with students responding “Yes Sir! We will practice critical thinking. Sir!” and in Pythonesque brilliance, one student speaking out with “I will not!”
The teaching of critical thinking is simply not suited to mass production education but it has never before been so accessible. When the media of fifty countries are just a mouse-click away and the greatest literature of the past several millennia is free for the download, we in the U.S. and the developed world have an unparalleled opportunity to both practice and share critical thinking and to help make it a norm throughout the world. Will we do that or will we respond to fervor with fervor:
I do no thinking of my own. I bow and toe the line
I shout the words and fly the flag. Your God's no match for mine
About the author:
K. Titchenell is the author of SAT Practice: The New Verbal Section (Abacus Educational Services, 2004 ISBN: 0-9758796-0-X) a quick and delightful way to learn vocabulary, grammar, writing style, or
how to have fun preparing for the new SAT and similar exams requiring verbal skills.
The website ( http://www.abacus-es.com/sat/) contains extensive material on English vocabulary, usage, grammar, writing style, and testing resources.
Article Source: http://www.articles32.com
.: New Career Articles
1). Waiver Of Approval For Military Active Duty Services For People With A Criminal History
This article is about getting a Waiver of approval for active duty services in the military if you have a criminal history.
2). Comparison Of Army Tankers And Marine Tankers
This article is about how Army Tankers and Marine Tankers are different from each other, but with the same goal in mind.
3). How Do You Want To Be Treated?
A leader is best when people barely know that they exist, not so good when people obey and acclaim them, worse when they despise them.
4). Getting A Job With Help From Microsoft Office
Getting a new job can often be just as challenging and stressful as being employed! When job hunting, you have a large number of contacts to keep track of, CVs and covering letters to write, interviews to prepare for and appointments to keep.
5). How To Write A Great Cover Letter
Many people think that cover letters are a wasted effort and that employers skip right to the resume, but the truth is that a cover letter is the first thing an employer sees as a representation of who you are and needs to catch their interest and look professional.
6). Single Moms in the Military
This article provides information for single moms who want to join the military.
7). The ABC of Bartending Basics
A brief introduction to the life as a bartender and why it is so attractive.
.: Top Career Articles
1). Ancient Egyptian Boats
Egyptians pioneered the development of river craft and there were many different types built for various uses. Agricultural produce, troops, cattle,
2). Pharmacist Resume Samples Will Help You Create An Unmistakable Resume!
Pharmacist resumes must have information of your experience relevant to the position in a quick and clear format. Employers are interested in a highly qualified person and customer friendly attitude.
Apart from highlighting your qualifications, contact information, experience etc, the following points will provide a hint on how to prepare the resume for a Pharmacist position.
3). CeMAP Mock Exam Papers
Are you looking for CeMAP mock exam papers? If you are interested in becoming a mortgage advisor but finding it hard to pass the cemap exams, we can help!
Mostly, five-day cemap training courses in London are based on groups of around 10 people for ease of control and ability to interact with the tutor. The courses are extremely focused, intensive and prepare delegates for the CeMAP 1,2,3 exams.
4). Nursing facts that everyone should know
Most people say it is a career about caring. Others say it is a job about professional administration of medications and cure to patients. Some say it is the duty to work out predicaments by using critical thinking skills.
In whatever way you want to call it, nursing is, indeed, a conglomeration of all these beliefs and the faculty of many other skills.
5). Need a New Career? How to Become a Welder
Find out how to prepare for a welding career.
6). Employee Conflict Resolution
Doin' it Old School - Written by Arizona Human Resources Outsourcing Professionals
In most cases, employees will spend as much if not more time with each other than they do with family and friends when you take into account a 40+ work week. Employees will butt heads every now and again when you have a group of people with varying personalities in close proximity to one another for extended time periods.
7). The Female Firefighter
Firefighting is no longer just the domain of the male. Just like every other career, trade, or profession women have made inroads into this traditionally male territory.